Writing a critique, especially in the context of a conformation dog show, involves providing an objective and structured evaluation of the dog based on its adherence to the breed standard. A critique should be detailed, constructive, and balanced, highlighting both strengths and areas for improvement.
1. Gather Information
Before writing, ensure you have:
A copy of the breed standard for reference.
Notes from your observation of the dog during judging, including its physical attributes, movement, and temperament.
2. Start with an Overview
Provide a brief introductory statement about the dog.
Include the breed, sex, and age (if relevant).
Mention the dog's overall impression (e.g., "A well-balanced AmStaff with an appealing expression and strong movement.").
3. Describe Specific Features
Evaluate and describe the dog in the following categories:
Head and Expression
Comment on the size, shape, and proportions of the head relative to the breed standard.
Note the ear placement, eye shape and color, muzzle length, and bite.
Example: "The head is well-proportioned with correctly set, round-shaped eyes that give a keen expression. The muzzle is slightly shorter than ideal but still balanced."
Body and Proportions
Discuss the topline, neck, chest, and ribcage.
Include observations about the dog’s proportions (length vs. height).
Example: "The topline is strong and slopes slightly from the withers to the rump, with a deep, well-sprung ribcage that allows for efficient movement."
Legs and Feet
Examine bone structure, angulation, and foot shape.
Example: "The front legs are straight with strong pasterns, and the feet are compact and well-arched."
Coat and Color
Describe the texture, length, and color of the coat, noting any markings.
Example: "The coat is short, close, stiff to touch and glossy that is typical of the breed."
Movement
Analyze the dog’s gait, focusing on its reach, drive, and overall soundness.
Example: "The dog moves with effortless grace, demonstrating excellent reach and drive, though the rear movement could be more parallel."
Temperament
Comment on the dog’s behavior and adherence to the breed's typical temperament.
Example: "This dog displayed the confident and friendly demeanor expected of the breed, engaging well with the handler and judge."
4. Highlight Strengths and Areas for Improvement
Use positive language to acknowledge strengths.
Gently point out areas that could improve without being overly critical.
Example: "While the dog exhibits a beautiful head and strong topline, its rear angulation is slightly overextended, which affects its balance during movement."
5. Summarize
Provide a closing statement summarizing your overall impression.
Example: "Overall, this [breed] presents as a fine example of the breed standard with exceptional movement and a pleasing expression. Minor adjustments in rear angulation could enhance the dog’s overall balance."
6. Maintain Objectivity
Avoid personal biases or comparisons to other dogs in the ring.
Focus solely on the dog in question and how it measures against the breed standard.
7. Use Proper Tone and Terminology
Be professional and respectful in your language.
Use precise terminology relevant to the breed and conformation judging.
Sample Critique
“This 3-year-old Amstaff presents a balanced outline with a slightly-arched neck and a strong topline sloping slightly from the withers to the rump. Her head is proportionate with dark, expressive eyes and correctly set ears. The coat is of excellent texture, short, close and stiff to touch. She moved with grace, showing good reach in the front and strong drive from the rear, although her rear movement could be slightly more parallel. She exhibited that lively and courageous temperament characteristic of the breed, engaging confidently with the judge and handler. A lovely example of the breed with only minor faults that do not detract from her overall quality.”
By following this structure, you can craft an effective and professional critique that is both insightful and helpful.